C-270, self-defence and the *decision to charge*
MPs debated C-270's proposed home-entry presumptions alongside an earlier Crown-screening alternative. The bill deserves scrutiny of how each route would affect the decision to charge.
Opinion
MPs spent Thursday's debate on Bill C-270 arguing over what the law should presume when someone enters a home unlawfully. One of the clearest disagreements concerned what happens after the incident: the decision to lay a criminal charge.
Conservative sponsor Sandra Cobena wants new home-entry presumptions in the Criminal Code. Liberal MP Doug Eyolfson defended the existing self-defence law while arguing that earlier Crown screening could reduce improperly laid charges. That exchange deserves more attention than the familiar argument over whether Canadians can defend themselves.
For a licensed owner, the quality and timing of that first decision matter. A prosecution can require someone to organize their life around defending what they say was a lawful response. I want Parliament to test how its proposed remedy would address that burden, with the evidence and safeguards visible.
C-270 remains at second reading. November 19 brought debate; the allotted hour expired and the order went to the bottom of the order of precedence. The proposal has yet to pass the House or change the law.
Two presumptions, different wording
Present section 34 protects a person who believes on reasonable grounds that force is being used or threatened against them or another person, acts for a defensive purpose, and responds reasonably in the circumstances. The court considers relevant circumstances, including the threat, weapons, the person's role, relationships and the nature and proportionality of the response.
Cobena's first-reading text would add a provision about force, including lethal force, that a person deems reasonably necessary against someone who entered a dwelling-house without legal entitlement, where the person using force is lawfully present. Two proposed presumptions follow. A presumption supplies a legal starting point for assessing the facts.
Proposed subsection 34(2.1) concerns the entrant's intent. Knowing entry without legal entitlement would establish an intention to use force against someone lawfully present, unless evidence shows otherwise.
Proposed subsection 34(2.2) goes to the defence itself. It says the conditions in subsection 34(1) would be presumed met when someone uses force, including lethal force, against a person who entered without legal entitlement, in a dwelling where the person using force is lawfully present.
The second provision does not repeat the first's express references to knowing entry and evidence to the contrary. Cobena described the proposed presumptions as rebuttable and said courts would continue examining facts. MPs should examine how that explanation fits each provision's actual wording. Those differences deserve clear answers during scrutiny of the bill.
Eyolfson raised mistaken entry and intimate-partner violence as situations where he feared an entry-based presumption could protect unjustified force. These are concerns about the proposal's reach. They require a drafting answer from its supporters. Cobena's objective of protecting a lawful resident deserves equally serious attention from opponents.
An earlier decision on charges

Eyolfson also acknowledged the damage a criminal charge can cause and argued for prosecutorial screening before charges are laid. That gives the debate a practical alternative to examine: when an independent prosecutor considers the evidence supporting self-defence.
British Columbia's current Charge Assessment Guidelines show how one existing system approaches that decision. Police retain authority to lay an Information, the document that initiates a charge. The BC Prosecution Service expects prior Crown approval unless that is impracticable, or exhaustion of its review process where approval was refused.
The Crown's usual two-part standard asks: is there a substantial likelihood of conviction, and does the public interest require prosecution? The guideline expressly requires consideration of viable defences that remove a substantial likelihood of conviction. The standard continues through the prosecution.
Ontario's charge-screening directive uses a reasonable prospect of conviction and the public interest. Prosecutors must consider likely defences and information supporting them. Screening continues as evidence arrives; if the required standard falls away, the prosecution must end.
These published policies establish standards and responsibilities. They leave the performance question open: how promptly and consistently do authorities assess evidence supporting self-defence in the cases causing concern? A policy document alone cannot tell us how often a lawful resident bears an avoidable prosecution.
Earlier review also requires proper investigation. A prosecutor needs a reliable account of what happened. The aim should be a sound decision as early as the evidence allows, with scrutiny of unjustified violence preserved.
What Parliament should test
Cobena has identified a concern that deserves an answer: the burden on people who say they acted lawfully. Eyolfson's response offers something concrete to compare. MPs can examine a change to the defence's starting assumptions alongside a change in when prosecutors assess a case.
I would like scrutiny of C-270 to answer three practical questions. How would each presumption affect charging decisions? What safeguards address mistaken entry, disputed permission and violence between people who know each other? What do existing screening systems reveal about delays, withdrawn charges and the evidence available at the first decision?
Those questions need records and testimony from prosecutors, police, defence counsel and people who have been through the process. The November 19 speeches set out competing arguments. They provide no demonstrated reduction in charges or legal costs from this proposed bill, and no sound basis for promising either result.
Holdover's earlier Whitby analysis examined the boundary between defensive force and a later act after the threat had left. C-270 adds a different question: whether the proposed presumptions would improve decisions, and how earlier Crown review compares.
Lawful residents deserve prompt, evidence-based decisions and a clear explanation of how a proposed reform would help them. Parliament should use this debate to demand that work from both the bill's supporters and the authorities defending existing practice. A fair process should give people a practical chance to get back to their lives.
Sources
- House of Commons: November 19, 2026 Hansard, sitting 168
- House of Commons: official XML of the same sitting
- Parliament: C-270 current stage
- Parliament: C-270 first-reading text
- Justice Canada: Criminal Code, section 34
- BC Prosecution Service: Charge Assessment Guidelines, CHA 1
- Ontario: Crown Prosecution Manual, D.3, Charge Screening
Follow Canadian ownership and policy reporting through The Dispatch.