Ottawa wants another year if the gun ban falls. *Which firearm* justifies the wait?
Canada asks for a year if its gun ban falls. A reader asked which firearm would change class, then showed me a shotgun entry that still leaves out the reason the RCMP gave in court.
Opinion | Steve Coppola
After I wrote that Ottawa wants another year if the Supreme Court strikes down the 2020 gun ban, a reader got in touch. Canada said some firearms that used to be restricted would become non-restricted. He wanted to know if I could name one that would actually make that jump if the whole order fell.
I went back to paragraph 199 of the government’s written argument. It gives a category without naming a firearm. I listened to the part of Canada’s closing argument where counsel explained the concern. No model there either. I’d given readers an accurate account of what Ottawa said and left them in much the same position as before. They still had to take Ottawa’s word for it. Canada’s factum, paragraphs 198–200 · Counsel’s November 9 submission at 3:07:17
What would happen to the Colt AR-15?
The reader meant the whole May 2020 order. He wasn’t suggesting the Court would throw out cabinet’s power to make firearms regulations. Take the Colt AR-15. You can look it up by name on the old restricted list. In May 2020, cabinet added the new prohibition and, in section 4 of the same order, repealed the old restricted entry. The former restricted list, item 2(a) · The May 2020 order, sections 3 and 4
That second step matters. Strike only the new prohibition and the old entry could stay off the books. Throw out the whole order as invalid from the start and there’s a good argument that the Colt’s old restriction applies again. Canada’s filing covers several possible rulings. I couldn’t verify a named firearm that has to go from restricted to non-restricted in the reader’s whole-order example. The Court reserved judgment on November 10. The wording of any relief is still up to the judges. Supreme Court docket
Ottawa calls the prospect a public-safety concern and wants twelve months for cabinet to respond. I’d like the government to name a model, show us the provision that used to restrict it and explain why that provision would stay gone under the ruling it fears. An owner weighing permanent surrender or deactivation has a fair claim on that explanation. Even if the owners win, nobody can put a destroyed gun back in the safe. Holdover’s hearing report · Our reporting on the compensation and amnesty timelines
What the RCMP told the court about the MK12
When our exchange turned to the RCMP’s classification decisions, I asked him for an example. He sent me the model and the record so I could check it myself. His example, the Derya Arms MK12 shotgun, had been non-restricted before May 2020. That takes it out of the running for paragraph 199. He wanted me to see how the RCMP had explained its prohibition. Murray Smith’s testimony on its earlier status, p. 283

His March 2022 copy of the Firearms Reference Table listed the MK12 as prohibited under paragraph 87. A few lines down, the model description said it was “not a variant of the AR15.” I found the same wording in the RCMP’s public table dated November 16, 2026. It’s on page 29,512, under reference number 141379. RCMP table, MK12 entry (large PDF)
There’s an answer. In October 2020, a lawyer read that sentence back to Murray Smith, the government’s firearms expert. Smith said the RCMP considered the shotgun an AR-10 variant. Paragraph 87 covers the AR-10 as well as the AR-15. The next day, another lawyer asked Smith where the model description mentioned the AR-10. Smith agreed it was missing. He explained that the field gave a general description of the gun. Six years later, an owner can still read that entry from beginning to end without finding the reason Smith gave under oath. Smith on the AR-10, p. 97 · The follow-up, p. 286
Consider what an owner could have seen that spring. A May 14, 2020 printout still showed the MK12 as non-restricted. A June 16 printout showed it as prohibited. Both went into evidence. Smith’s position was that the regulation changed the gun’s status on May 1. The RCMP describes its table as an administrative reference used by police and other officials. If an owner had checked it nearly two weeks after the ban took effect, they’d have found the old answer. May 14 entry · June 16 entry · How the RCMP describes the table
The Canadian Coalition for Firearm Rights disputes the RCMP’s classification of this very shotgun in its Supreme Court filing. An owner could agree with the RCMP and still see the reader’s point. The table has room to explain why the MK12 resembles the AR-15. Surely it has room to name the firearm the RCMP actually relied on. CCFR’s argument, paragraph 83
Parliament heard this question in 1995
The reader also wondered whether Parliament had intended this power to cover so many firearms at once. On May 19, 1995, the Commons justice committee chair told Justice Minister Allan Rock that witnesses feared cabinet would keep adding guns to the prohibited list. The chair thought that fear was misplaced. Even so, he asked Rock to put clearer protection for hunting and competitive shooting into the bill. Rock pointed to the kinds of firearms government had banned and planned to ban. “Let the record speak for itself,” he said. The 1995 exchange
Parliament wrote a hunting and sporting-use limit into the Criminal Code and left the judgment about reasonable use to cabinet. It set no one- or two-model ceiling. What the reader put his finger on was the question MPs themselves were asking while they still had the bill in front of them. How much reassurance should an owner take from one minister’s account of how cabinet had used a power so far? Criminal Code, section 117.15(2)
He also got me to reconsider something I’d said about Bill C-21. I’d put too much weight on the backlash over hunting rifles when I explained why the Liberals pulled two amendments. He thought the timing mattered. The Liberals brought the proposals forward in November 2022, after MPs had heard witnesses and begun going through the bill clause by clause. On February 3, 2023, the committee withdrew G-4 and removed G-46 from the package before it had even been formally moved. Public Safety later acknowledged concerns about both hunting firearms and the need for more consultation. I think he had the fairer account. People who make time to testify ought to see what the government actually wants to pass. November 22 minutes · February 3 minutes · Public Safety’s answer to question 25
I’m grateful he wrote. I asked him which shotgun he meant, and he sent enough for anyone to check his work. I’d like the RCMP to put its AR-10 explanation where an MK12 owner would look for it. And I’d still like an answer to the question that started his first email. If a particular firearm is reason to make owners wait another year, which one does Ottawa have in mind?
Get Holdover’s weekly Dispatch for more reporting on the firearms appeals and what they mean for Canadian owners.
The amnesty file is still moving.
If this piece sent you back to government pages, do not wait for the next portal, Gazette, or court move to find you by accident.
The Dispatch follows Public Safety, RCMP, Canada Gazette, court, compensation, collection, and amnesty updates so the next change comes with the source that moved.
Safety note: the tracker is a worksheet for source hygiene, not legal advice or a substitute for current official guidance.